Chicago’s candidate list created a second problem.
The deadline question had an earlier reference point. During the 2022 election, former Mu’tamid Abu Haitham told Electoral Committee members that the election dates mattered and had to be followed. Ashraf separately reminded them of the scheduled nomination and campaigning windows. The organization’s own procedures had taught members to regard those dates as binding, not negotiable once a candidate list became strategically inconvenient.
Eight candidates were competing for six Electoral Body positions. Under the published schedule, the withdrawal period had already ended at Maghrib on June 29. After the final field became visible, two candidates withdrew.
The change transformed the mathematics of the race. Eight candidates for six positions meant at least two people would lose. Six candidates for six positions dramatically reduced the competition among the remaining names.
Fawzy described what he believed had happened:
“They found out that there are eight brothers from the shilla (a close-knit clique or circle of associates) competing for six positions. So the next day two of them withdraw. Because they don’t want to dilute the votes.”
His objection was not that candidates could never change their minds. It was that they did so after the deadline, once the full field showed that aligned candidates risked splitting their own support.
Fawzy challenged Abu Amr and Ali directly:
“The deadline for withdrawal passed on June 29. Why did you allow this?”
In a contemporaneous exchange, Fawzy cited the June 29 date in the administrative file and in the election table that had been circulated.
No equivalent reopening was offered to every candidate. Chicago received an exception after officials and candidates could see how the published field affected the preferred group.
The late withdrawals did not stand alone. They sat beside Ayman’s continued election activity and, as the July 8 “majlis” screenshots later exposed, a private coordination group containing current and former senior figures. One action reduced competition among aligned candidates; the others worked to concentrate support behind the leadership direction they wanted to advance.
The question for the sitting Majlis was whether the same rules had governed every candidate and every official. The record before it showed that they had not.