The most damaging concern about the channel did not come from technical metadata. It came from chronology.
Diwan said Abu Amr circulated or disclosed the substance of one message through WhatsApp before Fawzy received that message through the official Amir channel. Fawzy brought the sequence before the sitting Majlis, and the council was aware of it while the election dispute was still active.
The problem was obvious. Fawzy was the recognized American recipient. Abu Amr was the senior representative whose conduct and influence appeared throughout the complaints. Yet Abu Amr appeared to know what the channel would say before the Mu’tamid formally received it.
The incident did not by itself reveal exactly how Abu Amr learned the message. It did something more important for the internal investigation: it showed that the official order of communication could not be assumed to reflect the real order in which information was moving.
The council already had reasons to ask that question. Years earlier, Khalid had experienced a complaint in which Abu Amr appeared with a verbal answer before members saw the written authority. During the 2025 election, the same pattern seemed to reappear: action or knowledge first, formal communication later.
That chronology became the spine of the channel investigation.