The Dallas dispute was easier to understand because the violation appeared inside the count itself.
Members were selecting representatives for the Electoral Body. Each voter was allowed one choice, and candidates had been told not to vote for themselves. Murad was not a newcomer to Dallas: he had long held responsibility for the locality before being replaced and had maintained a friendship with Abu Amr stretching back decades. Critics of that closeness went so far as to deride him as Abu Amr’s “lackey,” a disparaging description of what they perceived as his deference rather than a verified explanation of his conduct. That longstanding relationship, and the way critics viewed it, influenced how Dallas members interpreted the later intervention from above; personal closeness alone does not establish why the reversal occurred. Murad cast two votes. One of them was for himself.
The problem emerged when the number of ballots did not match the number of valid voters. Members challenged the count, and Murad acknowledged what he had done in front of those present. Two Dallas members then submitted written complaints through the organization’s official structure.
The national leadership authorized a rerun. Dallas members returned on July 6 and repeated the election under the stated rules. The second vote produced a different result: Murad lost the position created by the first count, and two other members entered the Electoral Body.
For a time, the correction appeared settled. Dallas had identified a violation, documented it, obtained permission to repeat the vote, and produced a clean result.
A July 6 message in the Majlis group records Fawzy reporting that officials had detected what he called an error or corruption in Dallas and that the election would be repeated that day. In a later message, he reported the rerun’s changed result and named the participants who had replaced Murad. Those are contemporaneous communications, not merely a reconstruction after the dispute escalated.
Then the corrected result was reversed from above.
On July 11, Fawzy circulated the reversal inside the Majlis group. He said the earlier rerun had been approved but a new message attributed to the Amir would instead adopt the original result. The screenshot captures his reaction and his view that the reversal required the council to consider resigning.
A communication carrying the Amir’s authority restored the original outcome and returned Murad to the position produced by the first election. The reversal did not explain how his acknowledged double vote had become irrelevant. It simply replaced the corrected result with the result that had caused the complaint.
That sequence became one of the strongest examples cited by the sitting Majlis because there was little ambiguity about the underlying problem. Dallas had not merely alleged unfairness. It had found an extra vote, received an admission, and completed the remedy leadership authorized.
The organization then discarded its own remedy.
The significance of Dallas would later become even sharper when officials invoked “integrity” to remove Diwan from the Majlis race. In Dallas, a documented violation did not prevent leadership from restoring the original result. In Diwan’s case, procedural strictness became the reason to revoke a candidacy that had already been approved.
Dallas therefore gave the council a baseline. The rules could be flexible enough to preserve a disputed winner and rigid enough to remove a challenger.